VaggaPañcaviññāṇāsābhogātikathā

Abhidhammapiṭaka · Kathāvatthu · Vol. 37 · Section 1396

[1396] Sakavādin: The five consciousnesses (pañca viññāṇā) have mental engagement (ābhoga)? Paravādin: Yes. S.: Is it not the case that the five consciousnesses have arisen bases (vatthu) and arisen objects (ārammaṇa)? P.: Yes. S.: If the five consciousnesses have arisen bases and arisen objects, then indeed you should not say, "The five consciousnesses have mental engagement." … S.: Is it not the case that the five consciousnesses have pre-arisen bases and pre-arisen objects; internal bases and external objects; intact bases and intact objects; diverse bases and diverse objects; that they do not experience one another's resort and domain (gocara-visaya); that they do not arise without adverting (samannāhāra); that they do not arise without attention (manasikāra); that they do not arise uninterspersed [with other consciousness]; and that they do not arise neither before nor after [one another, i.e., simultaneously]? Is it not the case that the five consciousnesses do not arise in immediate succession (samanantarā) to one another? P.: Yes. S.: If the five consciousnesses do not arise in immediate succession to one another, then indeed you should not say, "The five consciousnesses have mental engagement."

English translation from the Pali (Siam Raṭṭha edition) — under review, not for citation.