MahāvaggavaggaSabbamatthītikathā

Abhidhammapiṭaka · Kathāvatthu · Vol. 37 · Section 382

[382] S. — Does Nibbāna exist? P. — Yes. S. — Is what exists Nibbāna? P. — What exists may be Nibbāna, or may be non-Nibbāna. S. — Acknowledge the refutation (niggaha): If Nibbāna exists, and what exists may be Nibbāna or may be non-Nibbāna, then Nibbāna is non-Nibbāna, and non-Nibbāna is Nibbāna. What you say there — namely, that it can be said, "Nibbāna exists; what exists may be Nibbāna, or may be non-Nibbāna," whereby Nibbāna is non-Nibbāna and non-Nibbāna is Nibbāna — is wrong. But if Nibbāna is not non-Nibbāna, and non-Nibbāna is not Nibbāna, then indeed it should not be said, "Nibbāna exists; what exists may be Nibbāna, or may be non-Nibbāna." What you say there — namely, that it can be said, "Nibbāna exists; what exists may be Nibbāna, or may be non-Nibbāna," whereby Nibbāna is non-Nibbāna and non-Nibbāna is Nibbāna — is wrong.

English translation from the Pali (Siam Raṭṭha edition) — under review, not for citation.