VaggaJhānasaṅkantikathā

Abhidhammapiṭaka · Kathāvatthu · Vol. 37 · Section 1753

[1753] S.: Does one pass over (saṅkamati) from the third jhāna to the fourth jhāna? P.: Yes. S.: The adverting (āvajjanā) … the resolve (paṇidhi) that there is for the arising of the third jhāna — is that very same the adverting … the resolve for the arising of the fourth jhāna? P.: It should not be said thus. … S.: One passes over from the third jhāna to the fourth jhāna, and yet it should not be said that the adverting … the resolve that there is for the arising of the third jhāna is that very same adverting … resolve for the arising of the fourth jhāna? P.: Yes. S.: Does the fourth jhāna arise for one who is not adverting … does it arise for one who is not resolving? P.: It should not be said thus. … S.: Does not the fourth jhāna arise for one who is adverting … does it not arise for one who is resolving? P.: Yes. S.: If the fourth jhāna arises for one who is adverting … arises for one who is resolving, then indeed, good sir, it should not be said, "One passes over from the third jhāna to the fourth jhāna." S.: Does one pass over from the third jhāna to the fourth jhāna? P.: Yes. S.: Does the third jhāna arise for one attending to rapture (pīti) as a danger (ādīnava)? P.: Yes. S.: Does the fourth jhāna arise for one attending to rapture as a danger? P.: It should not be said thus. … S.: Is the third jhāna accompanied by pleasure (sukha)? P.: Yes. S.: Is the fourth jhāna accompanied by pleasure? P.: It should not be said thus. … S.: Does one pass over from the third jhāna to the fourth jhāna? P.: Yes. S.: Is that very third jhāna itself the fourth jhāna? P.: It should not be said thus. …

English translation from the Pali (Siam Raṭṭha edition) — under review, not for citation.

This passage also appears in 1 other place