DhātuvibhaṅgasuttantabhājanīyaPañhāpucchakaUpādānagocchakavisajjanā

Abhidhammapiṭaka · Vibhaṅga · Vol. 35 · Section 141

[141] Seventeen elements (dhātu) are not clingings (nupādānā); the dhamma element (dhammadhātu) may be a clinging (upādāna), may be not a clinging. Sixteen elements are subject to clinging (upādāniya); two elements may be subject to clinging, may be not subject to clinging (anupādāniya). Sixteen elements are dissociated from clinging (upādāna-vippayutta); two elements may be associated with clinging (upādāna-sampayutta), may be dissociated from clinging. Sixteen elements should not be said to be "both clingings and subject to clinging"; they are subject to clinging but not clingings. The mind-consciousness element (manoviññāṇadhātu) should not be said to be "both a clinging and subject to clinging"; it may be subject to clinging but not a clinging; it may be such that it should not be said to be "subject to clinging but not a clinging." The dhamma element may be both a clinging and subject to clinging; may be subject to clinging but not a clinging; may be such that it should not be said either to be "both a clinging and subject to clinging" or to be "subject to clinging but not a clinging." Sixteen elements should not be said either to be "both clingings and associated with clinging" or to be "associated with clinging but not clingings." The mind-consciousness element should not be said to be "both a clinging and associated with clinging"; it may be associated with clinging but not a clinging; it may be such that it should not be said to be "associated with clinging but not a clinging." The dhamma element may be both a clinging and associated with clinging; may be associated with clinging but not a clinging; may be such that it should not be said either to be "both a clinging and associated with clinging" or to be "associated with clinging but not a clinging." Sixteen elements are dissociated from clinging and subject to clinging (upādāna-vippayutta-upādāniya); two elements may be dissociated from clinging and subject to clinging, may be dissociated from clinging and not subject to clinging (upādāna-vippayutta-anupādāniya), may be such that they should not be said either to be "dissociated from clinging and subject to clinging" or to be "dissociated from clinging and not subject to clinging."

English translation from the Pali (Siam Raṭṭha edition) — under review, not for citation.

This passage also appears in 4 other places