DhātuvibhaṅgasuttantabhājanīyaPañhāpucchakaKilesagocchakavisajjanā

Abhidhammapiṭaka · Vibhaṅga · Vol. 35 · Section 142

[142] Seventeen elements (dhātu) are not defilements (kilesa); the dhamma-element (dhammadhātu) may be a defilement, may not be a defilement. Sixteen elements are subject to defilement (saṅkilesika); two elements may be subject to defilement, may be not subject to defilement (asaṅkilesika). Sixteen elements are undefiled (asaṅkiliṭṭha); two elements may be defiled (saṅkiliṭṭha), may be undefiled. Sixteen elements are dissociated from defilements (kilesa-vippayutta); two elements may be associated with defilements (kilesa-sampayutta), may be dissociated from defilements. Sixteen elements should not be described as both defilements and subject to defilement; they are both subject to defilement and not defilements. The mind-consciousness element (manoviññāṇadhātu) should not be described as both a defilement and subject to defilement; it may be both subject to defilement and not a defilement, and may not be describable as both subject to defilement and not a defilement. The dhamma-element may be both a defilement and subject to defilement; may be both subject to defilement and not a defilement; and may not be describable either as both a defilement and subject to defilement or as both subject to defilement and not a defilement. Sixteen elements should not be described either as both defilements and defiled or as both defiled and not defilements. The mind-consciousness element should not be described as both a defilement and defiled; it may be both defiled and not a defilement, and may not be describable as both defiled and not a defilement. The dhamma-element may be both a defilement and defiled; may be both defiled and not a defilement; and may not be describable either as both a defilement and defiled or as both defiled and not a defilement. Sixteen elements should not be described either as both defilements and associated with defilements or as both associated with defilements and not defilements. The mind-consciousness element should not be described as both a defilement and associated with defilements; it may be both associated with defilements and not a defilement, and may not be describable as both associated with defilements and not a defilement. The dhamma-element may be both a defilement and associated with defilements; may be both associated with defilements and not a defilement; and may not be describable either as both a defilement and associated with defilements or as both associated with defilements and not a defilement. Sixteen elements are dissociated from defilements but subject to defilement (kilesavippayutta-saṅkilesika); two elements may be dissociated from defilements but subject to defilement, may be dissociated from defilements and not subject to defilement (kilesavippayutta-asaṅkilesika), and may not be describable either as dissociated from defilements but subject to defilement or as dissociated from defilements and not subject to defilement.

English translation from the Pali (Siam Raṭṭha edition) — under review, not for citation.

This passage also appears in 4 other places